All articles
Startups & BusinessNovember 12, 2026 6 min read

The Equity Deal That Almost Sank Us: A Framework for Agencies Taking Stock Instead of Cash

Taking equity from a client sounds like free lottery tickets. It isn't. Here's the framework we use to decide when stock beats a wire transfer — and when it's just a discount with extra paperwork.

A founder once offered us 6% of his company in exchange for building the MVP. We said yes. Three years later that 6% was worth exactly what the paper it was printed on cost us — and we'd turned down two paying contracts to make room for it. This is the framework we built afterwards so we'd never make that mistake again.

Why agencies keep saying yes to equity

The pitch is seductive. A charismatic founder walks in, can't quite afford your rate, but offers you a slice of something that could be worth millions. You do the mental math at a 10x outcome, forget about the 90% of startups that die, and sign.

Agencies take equity for three honest reasons and one dishonest one:

  • The client genuinely can't pay cash yet and the opportunity looks real.
  • You want exposure to upside beyond billable hours.
  • You want to learn a domain on someone else's time.
  • (The dishonest one) You're desperate for the logo and equity feels less humiliating than discounting.

If you're in bucket four, stop reading and go read our piece on scope and pricing in agency work. Equity will not fix a sales problem.

The three deal shapes, ranked

In our experience there are only three equity structures worth signing. Everything else is a variation of one of them with extra legal fees.

1. SAFE or convertible note at a capped valuation

You invoice at your normal rate. The client doesn't pay cash — instead, the unpaid invoice converts into a SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) at the next priced round, usually with a valuation cap and a discount (20% is typical).

This is our preferred structure. Why:

  • Your contribution is denominated in dollars, not percentages. If scope doubles, your stake grows.
  • You convert alongside professional investors who've done diligence for you.
  • If the company never raises, you have a clean debt claim (with a note) or a worthless piece of paper (with a SAFE) — either way, the accounting is simple.

2. Direct common stock with vesting

You get X% of the cap table on day one, but it vests over the engagement — typically monthly over 12 to 24 months, with a 3-month cliff. If the client fires you or disappears, unvested shares revert.

Use this only when:

  • You're taking a board-adjacent role, not just shipping features.
  • The founder has already raised a priced round so the 409A valuation is defensible.
  • You're comfortable with common-stock preferences (you're last in line at exit).

3. Revenue share with a buyout clause

Not technically equity, but the same spirit. You take X% of revenue from the product you build, capped at some multiple of your original fee (say 3x), with the client's right to buy you out early.

Great for e-commerce builds, marketplaces, and anything where revenue starts within 6 months of launch. Terrible for anything requiring a Series A to monetize.

The math nobody runs before signing

Before you say yes, run this calculation. We put it in a spreadsheet template every account manager uses.

# Expected value of an equity deal vs cash
cash_fee = 150_000              # what you'd normally charge
equity_stake = 0.05             # 5% common stock
dilution_to_exit = 0.60         # assume 60% dilution through future rounds
probability_of_exit = 0.10      # 10% chance of a real liquidity event
expected_exit_valuation = 20_000_000
years_to_exit = 6

final_stake = equity_stake * (1 - dilution_to_exit)
expected_payout = final_stake * expected_exit_valuation * probability_of_exit

# Discount for time value of money
discount_rate = 0.15
present_value = expected_payout / ((1 + discount_rate) ** years_to_exit)

print(f"Cash option: ${cash_fee:,.0f}")
print(f"Equity PV:   ${present_value:,.0f}")
print(f"Ratio:       {present_value / cash_fee:.2f}x")

Plug in honest numbers. In our experience, most equity deals come out to between 0.4x and 0.9x the cash option when you discount for risk and time. That doesn't mean don't do them — it means you should take equity only when the non-financial returns justify the discount: learning, relationships, portfolio prestige, or genuine conviction in the founder.

If you catch yourself fudging the probability of exit upward to make the math work, close the spreadsheet and bill cash.

The clauses that protect you

Agencies get eaten alive in equity deals because they negotiate like vendors, not investors. Here's what we now insist on, every time.

Information rights

You are a shareholder. You get quarterly financials, cap table updates, and notice of any financing round. Without this, you'll discover your stake got crushed in a down round via LinkedIn.

Pro-rata rights

The right (not obligation) to participate in future rounds to maintain your ownership percentage. Rarely used, but when a client becomes a rocket ship, this is how you avoid getting diluted into irrelevance.

Tag-along rights

If the founders sell their shares in a secondary, you get to sell a proportional amount of yours. Otherwise you can end up holding minority common stock in a company run by strangers.

A kill switch on the engagement

Separate the equity grant from the services agreement. We've seen agencies feel obligated to keep working on a dying project because they didn't want to "abandon their investment". Your services contract should have a normal 30-day termination clause. Your equity stake stands on its own after it vests.

Acceleration on change of control

If the company gets acquired mid-engagement, your unvested shares accelerate. Otherwise the acquirer cancels your contract on day one and you walk away with the vested portion only.

The portfolio rule

Here's the discipline that matters more than any single contract clause: cap your equity exposure as a percentage of annual revenue.

Our rule is simple. Equity-funded work cannot exceed 15% of forecasted annual revenue. If it does, we either turn down the next equity deal or raise cash rates to compensate.

This matters because equity is lumpy, illiquid, and mostly worthless. If you're taking 30% of your revenue in paper, you've turned your agency into a hedge fund with a development team attached. You still have to make payroll in actual currency, and "we're equity-rich" is not a thing you can tell engineers in December.

Treat your equity deals as a portfolio. Expect 70% to go to zero. Expect 25% to return 1-2x. Expect 5% to do something interesting. If the 5% doesn't eventually pay for the 70%, your deal selection is bad and you should stop.

When to just say no

Some deals are structured so badly that no amount of upside justifies them. Walk away when:

  • The founder won't share the cap table before you sign.
  • You're being offered a percentage of "the project" rather than the company. This is almost always a legal fiction.
  • The equity is contingent on vague milestones ("when we hit product-market fit") rather than time or clear events.
  • The founder has already given equity to three other agencies. Your stake will be diluted to nothing and your work will conflict with theirs.
  • The company's entire moat is the founder's charisma. You've met them once. That's not enough.

Also walk away when your gut says the founder is a bad actor. Equity binds you together for years. Cash lets you leave on Friday.

Where we'd start

If you've never done an equity deal and want to try one: pick a single client, structure it as a SAFE with a 20% discount and a reasonable cap, keep the dollar amount under 10% of your quarterly revenue, and use a startup lawyer who's papered at least fifty of these. Budget $3-5k in legal fees and don't try to save money by copying a template off the internet.

Then put the paperwork in a drawer and forget about it. If it ever becomes worth something, that'll be a nice surprise. If it doesn't, you learned the mechanics on a deal small enough not to hurt. Either way, you're one step closer to running an agency that owns its upside instead of just renting out hours.

#agency#pricing#equity#startups#founders

Want a team like ours?

72Technologies builds production software for the kind of teams who actually read this blog.

Start a project